01Search in Shrewsbury, NJ
Shrewsbury, NJ homes for sale & real estate.
Browse homes for sale in Shrewsbury, NJ, a historic, affluent borough known for top schools, colonial charm, and a central location near Red Bank. Shrewsbury offers single-family colonials and Capes, historic homes, and a small number of condos and townhomes, including neighborhoods such as the historic Sycamore Avenue corridor and established residential neighborhoods, with inventory ranging from attainable entry points to its most sought-after properties.
Shrewsbury is reached by Route 35, Sycamore Avenue, and the Garden State Parkway a short drive west, and the Red Bank and Little Silver stations on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line are minutes away with direct rail to New York Penn Station. Prices reflect local demand: condos and smaller homes start in the $400,000s to $500,000s, the bulk of single-family homes trade in the $600,000s to $800,000s, and larger colonials and estates climb above that.
Updated June 2026.
Search Shrewsbury listings, updated in real time.
Explore the latest homes for sale in Shrewsbury, NJ, updated in real time so you see accurate availability and pricing. Inventory features single-family colonials and Capes, historic homes, and a small number of condos and townhomes across the Shrewsbury market.
Shrewsbury is served by the Shrewsbury Borough School District, with Riverview Medical Center in Red Bank nearby and quick access to the Garden State Parkway a short drive west. Use the price-range pages below to narrow your search, or call 888-327-6555 for a neighborhood-by-neighborhood update.
25 Properties Available
02Explore Communities & Market
Explore Shrewsbury and nearby Monmouth communities.
Shrewsbury sits in central Monmouth County, close to a range of communities that suit different budgets and lifestyles. Compare the nearby towns below to weigh price, schools, commute, and character before you choose.
In western and central Monmouth County, buyers considering Shrewsbury also tour Red Bank (walkable downtown and arts), Little Silver (top schools and rail), Tinton Falls (central and 55+ options), and Eatontown. Comparing them side by side is the best way to weigh schools, lot size, taxes, and drive time before you choose.
Search Shrewsbury homes by price.
Jump straight to the price range that fits your search, browse the full Shrewsbury area guide, or check current open houses. Every link below is a live Shrewsbury page.
Browse Monmouth County towns & neighborhoods.
Explore our town-by-town guides near Shrewsbury and across Monmouth County. Each guide covers local neighborhoods, schools, commute options, and current listings.
Shrewsbury open houses.
Browse upcoming open houses in Shrewsbury, or register for weekly alerts. Call 888-327-6555 to schedule a private showing any day of the week.
Homes for sale by property type.
Explore every type of home in and around Shrewsbury through our Monmouth County property pages: single-family homes, luxury estates, townhomes and condos, new construction, 55+ communities, and multi-family investment properties.
The Shrewsbury market, by the numbers.
Shrewsbury sees consistent buyer demand from families, professionals, and move-up buyers, and well-priced homes move quickly. Inventory is limited, which keeps competition strong for the most desirable properties.
Updated June 2026.
Within Shrewsbury, the best-located, larger, and updated homes sell at the top of the range, while smaller homes, townhomes, and condos offer the more attainable entry points. Call 888-327-6555 for a street-by-street breakdown.
Why buy a home in Shrewsbury.
- Location in central Monmouth CountyShrewsbury sits in central Monmouth County, with the historic Shrewsbury village and Christ Church, The Grove shopping, and nearby Red Bank dining and arts and an easy reach to the wider Monmouth County market.
- Schools and communityShrewsbury is served by the Shrewsbury Borough School District, a major reason buyers choose the area, along with its established neighborhoods and local amenities.
- Commuter accessShrewsbury connects to New York and the region via Route 35, Sycamore Avenue, and the Garden State Parkway a short drive west, and the Red Bank and Little Silver stations on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line are minutes away with direct rail to New York Penn Station.
- Lifestyle and amenitiesResidents enjoy the historic Shrewsbury village and Christ Church, The Grove shopping, and nearby Red Bank dining and arts, with parks, dining, and shopping close by.
- Steady demandThe combination of location, schools, and access keeps Shrewsbury in consistent demand among families, professionals, and move-up buyers, supporting long-term values.
Amenities & community overview.
- Browse all homes for sale in Shrewsbury or explore the wider Monmouth County market.
- Compare Shrewsbury neighborhoods and home styles before choosing, from attainable options to its premier properties.
- Weigh your commute: Route 35, Sycamore Avenue, and the Garden State Parkway a short drive west, plus the Red Bank and Little Silver stations on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line are minutes away with direct rail to New York Penn Station.
- Explore the historic Shrewsbury village and Christ Church, The Grove shopping, and nearby Red Bank dining and arts, with parks, dining, and shopping nearby.
- Call 888-327-6555 for a live, neighborhood-by-neighborhood market update in Shrewsbury.
Resources for buyers & sellers.
Local and state government, schools, healthcare, transportation, parks, and financial assistance relevant to Shrewsbury, NJ buyers and sellers.
First-time home buyer programs near Shrewsbury.
First-time buyer in Shrewsbury or Monmouth County, NJ? The New Jersey Dream Homeownership Program from NJHMFA helps eligible buyers with affordable financing, down payment and closing-cost assistance, and homebuyer education. Special options are available for military members, public safety professionals, educators, and healthcare workers.
03Connect for Answers
Frequently asked questions.
What is the average home price in Shrewsbury, NJ?
Shrewsbury's median sale price has been around $720K, but the range is wide. Condos and smaller homes start in the $400,000s to $500,000s, the bulk of single-family homes trade in the $600,000s to $800,000s, and larger colonials and estates climb above that. Smaller homes, townhomes, and condos offer more attainable entry points, while larger or premier-location properties climb well above the median. Call 888-327-6555 for a current breakdown.
Why do buyers move to Shrewsbury?
Shrewsbury appeals to families, professionals, and move-up buyers for the historic Shrewsbury village and Christ Church, The Grove shopping, and nearby Red Bank dining and arts, for its access to Route 35, Sycamore Avenue, and the Garden State Parkway a short drive west, and for its place in central Monmouth County. The mix of lifestyle, location, and community keeps it among the more desirable choices in Monmouth County.
How are the schools in Shrewsbury, NJ?
Students in Shrewsbury are served by the Shrewsbury Borough School District, with Red Bank Regional High School for high school. Review the NJ Department of Education report cards linked on this page for current ratings and enrollment data.
How is the commute from Shrewsbury, NJ?
Shrewsbury connects to the region via Route 35, Sycamore Avenue, and the Garden State Parkway a short drive west. the Red Bank and Little Silver stations on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line are minutes away with direct rail to New York Penn Station. Many residents also use park-and-ride and express bus options toward New York.
What are the neighborhoods of Shrewsbury?
Shrewsbury is made up of several neighborhoods and sections, most notably the historic Sycamore Avenue corridor and established residential neighborhoods. Call 888-327-6555 and we will help you target the right neighborhood for your budget and lifestyle.
What kinds of homes are for sale in Shrewsbury?
Inventory in Shrewsbury features single-family colonials and Capes, historic homes, and a small number of condos and townhomes, along with periodic new construction. Browse the price-range pages on this site or call 888-327-6555 for current listings.
How much are property taxes in Shrewsbury, NJ?
Property taxes in Shrewsbury reflect the municipal, school, and county levies, and the exact bill depends on a home's assessed value. Always review the current rate and assessment for a specific property; the NJ Division of Taxation resource on this page covers rates, deductions, and appeals.
Are there townhomes, condos, or 55+ homes in Shrewsbury?
Yes, in varying supply. Alongside its single-family homes, Shrewsbury has townhome, condominium, or age-restricted options that are often the more attainable entry points into the area. See the price-range pages on this site or call 888-327-6555 for current listings.
Is new construction available in Shrewsbury?
New construction in Shrewsbury tends to be custom homes, tear-down rebuilds, and periodic smaller developments rather than large subdivisions. Inventory is limited, so call 888-327-6555 or register for alerts to hear about new listings first.
What is there to do in Shrewsbury?
Shrewsbury offers the historic Shrewsbury village and Christ Church, The Grove shopping, and nearby Red Bank dining and arts, with the wider Monmouth County parks, Jersey Shore beaches, and dining and shopping a short drive away.
Is Shrewsbury a good place to live and invest?
Shrewsbury sees consistent buyer demand from families, professionals, and move-up buyers, which supports long-term values. Returns depend on price, taxes, and property type, so review the numbers carefully; we can help you weigh your options for your goals.
What towns border Shrewsbury?
Shrewsbury is bordered by Red Bank, Little Silver, Tinton Falls, Eatontown, and Shrewsbury Township. Each nearby town has a different mix of price, schools, and character. We can help you compare them.
Can Four Point Realty help me buy or sell a home in Shrewsbury?
Yes. Four Point Realty, led by Naveen Sharma, helps buyers and sellers throughout Shrewsbury and Monmouth County with full-service representation and a listing fee starting at 1%*. Whether you are buying, relocating, or selling, call 888-327-6555 or request a free home value estimate.
Why choose Four Point Realty for your search.
Buying or selling a home is one of the biggest financial decisions you will make. Four Point Realty is a trusted NJ real estate resource led by Naveen Sharma, offering current listings, strong local market knowledge, and honest insights from the first showing to the closing table. Call 888-327-6555 today.
Naveen Sharma
Ready to buy? Work directly with Naveen, whether you're buying your first home, relocating, investing, or moving up to a larger house, we guide you every step of the way.
Thinking about selling? Our listing fee starts at 1%*, giving homeowners full-service representation while saving thousands in commission.
Listing fee starting at 1%*. Buyer agent compensation is separate and negotiated per transaction. Naveen Sharma is licensed in NJ & GA. Four Point Realty LLC is licensed in NJ, NY & GA.
Connect with our team βGaurav Sharma
Broker of Record (NY). Licensed in NJ, NY & GA. Gaurav leads the Four Point Realty agent team and guides clients through pricing, negotiation, and closing, keeping every transaction smooth, transparent, and on schedule. My goal is always to help you make smart decisions by providing market insights, expert negotiation, and personalized guidance.
*Listing commission starting at 1% of the sale price; terms and conditions apply. Contact Four Point Realty for full details. Four Point Realty is licensed in New Jersey, New York and Georgia. Equal Housing Opportunity. Β© Four Point Realty LLC.
























