01Search in Milltown, NJ
Milltown, NJ homes for sale & real estate.
Browse homes for sale in Milltown, New Jersey. Milltown is a charming, tightly knit borough of roughly 7,000 residents in western Middlesex County, where the Lawrence Brook flows out of Farrington Lake and pools behind a Main Street dam to form the Mill Pond at the town's center. Incorporated in 1889 and once home to a major Michelin tire factory, Milltown offers single-family homes, multi-family dwellings, and condos along a traditional Main Street, with generations of families putting down roots here.
Milltown's location is a big part of its appeal. The borough sits between the New Jersey Turnpike (Exit 9) and U.S. Route 1 and Route 18 , very close to Rutgers University and the greater New Brunswick area. That puts jobs, healthcare, shopping, and Northeast Corridor rail (at nearby New Brunswick station) all within minutes. Milltown generally prices around Middlesex County's ~$535,000 median, and its high-quality schools support strong demand.
Updated May 2026
Search Milltown listings, updated in real time.
Explore the latest homes for sale in Milltown, NJ , updated in real time so you see accurate availability and pricing. Inventory features single-family homes of every type, along with multi-family dwellings and condos, on the borough's quiet, walkable streets near the Mill Pond.
Milltown draws buyers for its small-town feel, schools, and location. The Milltown Public Schools district serves PreK-8 at Parkview and Joyce Kilmer schools, with high-schoolers attending Spotswood High School through a long-standing sending relationship. The Main Street downtown, with shops and churches by the Mill Pond, gives the borough a genuine center. Buyers comparing nearby options often look at East Brunswick, North Brunswick, New Brunswick, and Spotswood , all bordering or near Milltown and each with its own market. Four Point Realty helps buyers across Central Jersey find the right fit for their goals and budget.
48 Properties Available
- 1/2 2
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 1,590 SqFt$599,999Coming Soon - 1/42 42
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 2,221 SqFt$675,000Open 7/19 11AM-2PM - 1/48 48
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 2,221 SqFt$825,000New - 1/28 28
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 3,049 Sqft Lot$561,000New - 1/25 25
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 3,049 Sqft Lot$561,000New - 1/18 18
3 Beds 1 Bath 4,356 Sqft Lot$479,900Active 
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,504 SqFt$395,000Active-Attorney Review
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,504 SqFt$395,000Active- 1/40 40
3 Beds 3 Baths 0.43 Acres Lot$775,000Active - 1/39 39
3 Beds 2.5 Baths 0.43 Acres Lot$775,000Active - 1/36 36
3 Beds 1 Bath 0.29 Acres Lot$479,900Active - 1/16 16
4 Beds 2 Baths 1,818 SqFt$715,000Active - 1/21 21
4 Beds 1.5 Baths 1,627 SqFt$610,000Active-Attorney Review - 1/17 17
3 Beds 2 Baths 3,358 Sqft Lot$550,000Active - 1/54 54
3 Beds 1.5 Baths 1,480 SqFt$555,000Active-Attorney Review - 1/43 43
3 Beds 1 Bath 1,092 SqFt$535,000Price Dropped by $30K - 1/42 42
3 Beds 1 Bath 1,092 SqFt$535,000Price Dropped by $30K - 1/37 37
4 Beds 3.5 Baths 3,210 SqFt$950,000Active - 1/37 37
4 Beds 4 Baths 3,210 SqFt$950,000Active16 Phyllis Place, Milltown, NJ 08850
Listed by Keller Williams Realty West Monmouth
Single Family Home
- 1/26 26
3 Beds 1 Bath$440,000Price Dropped by $20K - 1/26 26
3 Beds 1 Bath 1,200 SqFt$440,000Price Dropped by $20K - 1/36 36
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,320 SqFt$475,000Under Contract - 1/36 36
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,320 SqFt$475,000Pending - 1/13 13
3 Beds 1.5 Baths 1,248 SqFt$530,000Under Contract
02Explore Communities & Market
Explore Milltown and nearby Middlesex communities.
Milltown is a compact, walkable borough. Homes near the Mill Pond and Main Street offer classic borough character close to shops and churches, while quieter residential streets toward the East Brunswick and North Brunswick borders give a more suburban feel. The whole borough sits within easy reach of Rutgers and New Brunswick.
Search Milltown homes by price.
Jump to a price range or property type that fits your search, browse the Milltown area guide, or check current open houses. Every link below is a live page.
Browse Middlesex County towns & neighborhoods.
Explore our town-by-town guides near Milltown and across Middlesex County. Each guide covers local neighborhoods, schools, commute options, and current listings.
Milltown open houses.
Browse upcoming open houses in Milltown, or register for weekly alerts. Call 888-327-6555 to schedule a private showing any day of the week.
Homes for sale by property type.
Explore every type of home in and around Milltown through our Middlesex County property pages: single-family homes, transit-oriented and suburban homes, townhomes and condos, new construction, 55+ active-adult communities, and multi-family investment properties.
The Milltown market, by the numbers.
The snapshot below reflects the broader Middlesex County market as a baseline. Milltown pricing varies by neighborhood, street, and property type, so treat these figures as county-level context rather than a Milltown-only median. For a live, address-level analysis, ask us for a current comparative market report.
Updated May 2026
Within Milltown, updated single-family homes near the Mill Pond and in established neighborhoods command the most, while smaller homes and multi-family properties offer more attainable entry points and rental upside. Call 888-327-6555 for a current read on prices and inventory. Call 888-327-6555 for a street-by-street breakdown.
Why buy a home in Milltown.
- Mill Pond and Small-Town CharmMilltown is built around the Mill Pond, formed by a Main Street dam on the Lawrence Brook - a scenic centerpiece that gives the borough a distinctive, walkable, small-town character.
- High-Quality Local SchoolsMilltown Public Schools serves PreK-8 at Parkview and Joyce Kilmer schools, with high-schoolers attending Spotswood High School - strong schools that support home values.
- Next to Rutgers and New BrunswickMilltown sits very close to Rutgers University and the greater New Brunswick area, putting major employers, hospitals, and Northeast Corridor rail within minutes.
- Turnpike Exit 9 and Routes 1/18Positioned between the Turnpike at Exit 9 and U.S. Route 1 and Route 18, Milltown offers easy access in every direction across Central Jersey.
- Variety of HousingFrom single-family homes to multi-family dwellings and condos, Milltown offers a range of options for first-time buyers, families, and investors in a settled community.
Amenities & community overview.
- Browse all homes for sale in Milltown or explore the wider Middlesex County market.
- Compare Milltown neighborhoods and home styles before choosing, from attainable options to its premier properties.
- Weigh your commute: the New Jersey Turnpike, the Garden State Parkway, Interstate 287, US Route 1, and Route 18, plus the NJ Transit Northeast Corridor line stops in New Brunswick, Edison, Metuchen, and Woodbridge with direct trains to Newark and New York Penn Station.
- Explore Rutgers University, the Northeast Corridor rail line, and the Raritan River waterfront, with parks, dining, and rail access nearby.
- Call 888-327-6555 for a live, neighborhood-by-neighborhood market update in Milltown.
Resources for buyers & sellers.
Local and state government, schools, healthcare, transportation, parks, and financial assistance relevant to Milltown, NJ buyers and sellers.
First-time home buyer programs near Milltown.
First-time buyer in Milltown or Middlesex County, NJ? The New Jersey Dream Homeownership Program from NJHMFA helps eligible buyers with affordable financing, down payment and closing-cost assistance, and homebuyer education. Special options are available for military members, public safety professionals, educators, and healthcare workers.
03Connect for Answers
Frequently asked questions.
What is the average home price in Milltown, NJ?
Milltown generally prices around Middlesex County's roughly $535,000 median, supported by its strong schools and location near Rutgers. Updated single-family homes command the most, while smaller homes and multi-family properties offer more attainable entry points. Call 888-327-6555 for current pricing.
Is Milltown, NJ a good place to live?
Many buyers choose Milltown for its small-town charm, high-quality schools, and prime location next to Rutgers and New Brunswick. Built around the scenic Mill Pond, it's a tightly knit borough with a walkable Main Street.
How is the commute from Milltown to NYC?
Milltown doesn't have its own station, but it sits between Turnpike Exit 9 and Routes 1 and 18, and nearby New Brunswick offers NJ Transit Northeast Corridor rail to New York Penn Station. The location makes commuting in several directions convenient.
What are the schools like in Milltown?
Milltown Public Schools serves PreK-8 at Parkview School (PreK-3) and Joyce Kilmer School (4-8). High-school students attend Spotswood High School through a long-standing sending/receiving relationship. The district is known for quality and small size.
What is the Mill Pond in Milltown?
The Mill Pond sits at the center of Milltown, formed by a dam on the Lawrence Brook under Main Street as the brook flows from Farrington Lake. It's the borough's scenic centerpiece and a nod to its mill-town origins, including the former Michelin factory.
How are property taxes in Milltown, NJ?
Taxes are based on assessed value and the borough's tax rate, with school costs a component (including tuition for Spotswood High School). Rates change over time, so review current figures for any specific home. The NJ Division of Taxation resource on this page covers rates and appeals.
Is Milltown good for families?
Yes - its high-quality PreK-8 schools, walkability, Mill Pond setting, and small-town feel make Milltown especially popular with families. We can help you compare it with neighboring towns based on your priorities.
Which towns border Milltown?
Milltown borders North Brunswick to the west and East Brunswick to the east, and sits close to New Brunswick, Spotswood, and South River. Its location near Rutgers and the greater Brunswick area is a major draw.
Are there multi-family homes in Milltown?
Yes - Milltown's housing mix includes multi-family dwellings and apartments alongside single-family homes and condos, offering options for owner-occupants and investors. We can help you evaluate specific properties.
Is there new construction in Milltown?
Land for new building is limited in this built-out borough, but some new development and renovations occur. See our new construction page or call 888-327-6555 for current options nearby.
Can Four Point Realty help me sell my home in Milltown?
Yes. We list and market homes throughout Milltown with a listing fee starting at 1%, full-service representation, and pricing built on real, local comparables. Request a free home value estimate to start.
How do I get alerts for new listings in Milltown?
Register for a free account and set your filters by price, bedrooms, and property type to receive instant alerts, or call 888-327-6555 and we'll set up a custom search for you.
Why work with Four Point Realty in Milltown?
Four Point Realty is a New Jersey brokerage headquartered nearby in Woodbridge, with firsthand knowledge of Milltown's Mill Pond neighborhoods and its prized location near Rutgers. We offer full-service buyer representation and a listing fee starting at 1%. Call 888-327-6555 to get started.
Why choose Four Point Realty for your search.
Buying or selling a home is one of the biggest financial decisions you will make. Four Point Realty is a trusted NJ real estate resource led by Naveen Sharma, offering current listings, strong local market knowledge, and honest insights from the first showing to the closing table. Call 888-327-6555 today.
Naveen Sharma
Ready to buy? Work directly with Naveen, whether you're buying your first home, relocating, investing, or moving up to a larger house, we guide you every step of the way.
Thinking about selling? Our listing fee starts at 1%*, giving homeowners full-service representation while saving thousands in commission.
Listing fee starting at 1%*. Buyer agent compensation is separate and negotiated per transaction. Naveen Sharma is licensed in NJ & GA. Four Point Realty LLC is licensed in NJ, NY & GA.
Connect with our team βGaurav Sharma
Broker of Record (NY). Licensed in NJ, NY & GA. Gaurav leads the Four Point Realty agent team and guides clients through pricing, negotiation, and closing, keeping every transaction smooth, transparent, and on schedule. My goal is always to help you make smart decisions by providing market insights, expert negotiation, and personalized guidance.
*Listing commission starting at 1% of the sale price; terms and conditions apply. Contact Four Point Realty for full details. Four Point Realty is licensed in New Jersey, New York and Georgia. Equal Housing Opportunity. Β© Four Point Realty LLC.